Questions we tested
A hunch is a question until a source answers it. Each row is a question someone on the team brought, what the cards found, and whether it became a card.
| Question | Chapter | State | What we found |
|---|---|---|---|
| Was the land renamed "Palaestina" by Rome to cut its tie to the Jews? | 1 | cannot know | No ancient source states a motive. Historians differ, and the date itself is uncertain (130 or 136). Card era1-name-palestine, still a draft. |
| Does the Quran itself tie this land to the Children of Israel? | 1 | partly | Several verses speak of the Children of Israel being given a land or told to dwell in it (5:21, 7:137, 10:93, 17:104), but none of the verses quoted names the land; the reviewer removed our sentence that said the text ties them to it. Muslim scholars differ on what follows: most hold the promise was conditional or has lapsed. Card era1-quran-and-the-land: reviewed once, sent back. |
| Was taking control of land through war common in the 1940s, and how do the numbers compare? | 9 | supported | Germans expelled or fled, 12 to 14 million; the partition of India, about 14 to 15 million displaced; Palestinian Arabs in 1948, about 700,000. Draft cards ch9-…, not yet reviewed. The law changed in the same years (ch9-what-the-law-says). |
| Is Qatar the largest foreign funder of US universities, by the public filings? | 10 | untested | |
| Does this conflict get more media and UN attention than deadlier ones? By how much? | 10 | untested | |
| Is there evidence that foreign money caused that attention? | 10 | untested | |
| Does the Palestinian flag carry no Arabic script and no religious symbol, and why? | 11 | untested | |
| Is there any link between the flag's colours and the rainbow flag? | 11 | untested | |
| Which Western groups support the Palestinian cause most, by the polls, and what reasons do they give? | 11 | untested | |
| Does the law of genocide turn on how many were killed, or on intent? What did courts require? | 5 | supported | On intent. The Convention says "in whole or in part"; courts read that as a substantial part. Srebrenica, about 8,000 dead, was ruled a genocide; other mass killings in Bosnia were not. When intent is inferred from conduct, the ICJ requires it to be the only reasonable inference. Draft card gen-recognised-cases, not yet reviewed. |
| What do the numbers show about what Israel could do in Gaza and what it did? | 5 | partly | The case that the intent test is not met is real but not decisive. Against it: the aid ban of 2 March to 19 May 2025, the IPC famine finding of August 2025, and the officials' statements the ICJ quoted. The ICJ has not ruled. Draft card gen-capacity-and-conduct, not yet reviewed. |
| Who refused which peace offer, and what pressure was each side under at the time? | 12 | untested | |
| In Israel, is "left or right" mainly about the conflict and security, unlike in America? | 13 | mostly supported | Surveys put the conflict first, then religion and culture, then the economy. In a 2025 Pew survey, 54% of the Israeli left, 29% of the centre and 7% of the right thought a Palestinian state could coexist with Israel. The Israel Democracy Institute says the divide has grown more like the American one. Draft card ch13-left-and-right-in-israel, not yet reviewed. |
| Is a state defined around one people or religion unusual? How many are there, and how do they treat minorities? | 13 | supported | Common, not unique. Pew counts 43 states with an official religion and 40 more that favour one. Citizenship by descent or ethnic tie exists in Germany, Greece, Ireland, Armenia and Israel. Saudi Arabia and Iran differ in kind: religious law is state law. Draft card ch13-nation-states-compared; several of its facts are still short of three sources. |
| Was the United States founded around open immigration, by its own early laws? | 13 | not supported | The 1790 Naturalization Act limited citizenship to free white persons, and the 1924 Act set national-origins quotas, which ended only in 1965. Same draft card. |
| Do the Gulf states deny citizenship and equal rights to the migrants who are most of their workforce? | 13 | untested | |
| Do Muslim minorities in the West vote for the left while holding conservative social views? | 13 | untested | |
| Do Haredi voters rank religious law above democratic principles, by the surveys? Is sector politics unusual in a democracy? | 13 | untested | |
| Do minority groups in America move to the right as they settle? For which groups, and by how much? | 13 | untested | |
| Are Jews and Arabs near parity in number between the river and the sea? Who counts, and who disputes it? | 12 | supported | Near parity is the best-supported reading (the demographers DellaPergola and Soffer): about 60% Jewish counting Israel and the West Bank, just above 50% once Gaza is added. A US-Israeli research group says the Palestinian count is inflated by 1.1 to 1.4 million; those demographers reject that. The two statistics bureaus both count about 300,000 East Jerusalem Arabs. Draft card ch12-one-state-or-two-and-the-numbers, in review. |
| Do Likud voters live in the same towns and neighbourhoods as opposition voters, more than Haredi, Arab and settler voters do? | 13 | partly | From the Central Elections Committee's own results by polling station, for 2022 and 2026 (docs/election-map.md). In both elections Likud voters are far less separated from opposition voters than from Haredi or Arab-party voters (separation index: Likud 0.37 then 0.42, Haredi 0.62 then 0.70, Arab parties 0.93 then 0.94). But they share polling stations with opposition voters only about as often as chance predicts, and Religious Zionism's voters sit closer to Likud's than the opposition's do. National totals match the committee's pages for every list in both years; two 2022 numbers were also recomputed independently. |
| Does the way groups were treated in Israel's first decades still show in how they vote? | 13 | untested |
States: untested, supported (cards say so, with sources), partly, not supported (we looked and the evidence is against it or absent), cannot know (no source can settle it).