Needs a person
A card lands here after its rounds of writing and review end without reaching verified. Agents stop at that point: going round again invites cutting an awkward fact or padding with a weak source. Each row says exactly what is missing and where it might be found.
A person settles a row by reading the source and giving the page and the words, or by deciding the card should say less.
Chapter 3: 1937 to 1948
Three writing rounds, three review rounds, a pass under the record rule and a final review by a fresh reviewer (2026-11-20). All three cards are draft. Every quote on them is found on its page, and every sentence of each answer is tied to a fact. The attack round says weakened.
| Card | What is missing | Where it might be found |
|---|---|---|
era3-partition-1947 | The Arab League's cable of 15 May 1948 has no scholar or reference work reporting what it says. | UN Security Council records for May 1948; a monograph on the 1948 war. |
era3-partition-1947 | Land ownership in 1945 and the 1946 population each have one reader. Two sources disagree on public land. | The original Village Statistics 1945; the Survey of Palestine. |
era3-partition-1947 | Transjordan's dissent rests on two historians who are the two sides of the argument. | Rogan and Shlaim, The War for Palestine; Morris, 1948. |
era3-exodus-causes-1948 | Morris's phrase "partial ethnic cleansing" is on the card in his own words, with no second source reporting it. | His book The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem Revisited; his full 2004 interview in Haaretz. |
era3-exodus-causes-1948 | That return was barred rests on one scholar. | Morris on the Israeli cabinet's decision of June 1948. |
era3-exodus-causes-1948 | The UN's own counts differ (472,000; 500,000; over 700,000; 750,000). The card gives all four and says so. | A person decides whether to lead with one, and which. |
era3-jewish-refugees-arab-countries | No count of Jews who left Arab countries from a source that is neither Israeli nor Jewish. | UN or academic demographic studies; national censuses of Iraq, Egypt, Morocco. |
era3-jewish-refugees-arab-countries | The dispute over the departures from Iraq in 1950 and 1951 is not on the card. | Scholarly histories of Iraqi Jewry. |
Settled since the first list: the UN refugee office's 1957 statement was read first-hand, and its words do not name Jews; the card now says so.
Chapter 1: roots, names and scripture
Three writing rounds, three review rounds, a pass under the record rule and a final review (2026-11-20). All three cards are draft.
| Card | What is missing | Where it might be found |
|---|---|---|
era1-quran-and-the-land | The "readers" of each verse are other editions of the same text. A person decides whether that is enough. | A scholarly work that states what the verses say, such as The Study Quran. |
era1-quran-and-the-land | The reading that the grant still stands has one first-hand voice; two others reach us second-hand. | The scholars' own essays or interviews. |
era1-quran-and-the-land | The identification of the "farthest mosque" with Jerusalem lacks a reliable source on the card. | Classical commentary on 17:1; an encyclopaedia of Islam. |
era1-jewish-presence-through-centuries | Two facts fall below the source floor: how and when Jews became a minority, and the scale of dispersal. | Scholarship on the Byzantine-era decline. |
era1-jewish-presence-through-centuries | One fact joins three claims to three sources, one each. | Split it, or source each part. |
era1-arab-and-muslim-presence | The UN committee's 1946 population figure has one reader. | A demographer's own tables for 1922, 1931 and 1946. |
The cards era1-name-israel-judah-judea, era1-name-palestine and era1-rulers-timeline have not been reviewed yet.